Sunday, May 27, 2018

No Paybacks for Villarreal?




The runoff race for Leander mayor is in full swing, and the campaigns are taking their best swings at each other.  Team Vic has been running ads on Facebook.  One of the claims is that Vic Villarreal won't owe any paybacks or favors to anyone for campaign contributions unlike his opponent.  This claim deserves a closer look since Villarreal has received over $20,000 in contributions compared to Troy Hill who has received about half as much according to the most recent campaign finance reports found on the city's website. (See https://www.leandertx.gov/citysecretary/page/elections2018 for the reports.)

Here is a summary of the candidates' contributions reported with a few breakdowns  by  contributor's city, contributor type (PAC or not), and contributor's area of interest.


Villarreal Hill
TOTAL CONTRIBUTIONS  $  21,880.00 100%  TOTAL CONTRIBUTIONS  $  11,351.00 100%
PACs (Builders/Developers)  $    2,100.00 10%  PACs (Pro-business)  $    5,401.00 48%
Contribution categories: Contribution categories:
Real Estate & Development  $  19,550.00 89%  Real Estate & Development  $    3,250.00 29%
Financing  $        500.00 2%  Financing  $                 -   0%
Other  $    1,450.00 7% Other  $    2,100.00 18%
Unknown  $        630.00 3%  Unknown (cash and in-kind)  $    6,001.00 53%
Leander contributors  $    3,300.00 15%  Leander contributors  $    3,750.00 33%
One thing appears certain.  Leander is expected to grow, and those in the business of development are showing their interest in the mayor's race through significant contributions.  Villarreal has received almost $20,000 in contributions that trace to individuals, businesses, trusts, or PACs with a financial interest in the city's future development.  The category includes developers, civil engineers, real estate attorneys, city consultants, home builders, construction, and realtors.  That's 89% of his contributions. 

Villarreal currently has received less contributions from people or businesses who call Leander home with $3,300 as compared to $3,750 for Troy Hill. 

The Villarreal PAC money of $2,100 is from builders and developers.  Hill has about half of his contributions ($5,000 cash plus in-kind donations) from the Texas Stronger PAC based out of Georgetown.  The PAC describes itself as pro-business.  Much has been claimed about Hill's relationship with Andy Pitts; however, at this time Pitts does not appear on the finance reports of Hill's campaign nor the Texas Stronger PAC reports found on the Texas Ethics Commission website.  As many citizens note, the problem with PACs is the delay in transparency for pop-up ones such as this.  The most recent filing for the PAC lists a contributor with real estate interests.  Time will tell.

Both candidates are getting sizeable donations from contributors with financial interests in Leander's growth.  Villarreal is getting much more money so you might say they are betting on Team Vic.  As for Team Vic's claim that he'll be no-strings-attached Mayor Villarreal, I'd rate the claim as doubtful.  It would be refreshing to see lots of regular citizens giving financial support to the campaigns, but that is not the case for either candidate.

Below is the full detail of the contributors (names withheld although those can be found on the campaign finance reports at the Leander City website).

VILLARREAL CAMPAIGN FINANCE REPORT - CONTRIBUTORS



City  Amount  Occupation Employer Notes
Austin  $        500.00 Attorney McCall,Parkhurts,Horton Public finance
Richardson  $        250.00 Consulting - Engineering/Architecture/Planning PAC
Cedar Park  $        250.00
Trust works for JL Powers:  "He has specialized in public/private ventures", " Kaplan is well versed in planning and development issues" 
Austin  $    1,000.00 Land Developer Self
Austin  $    1,000.00 Land Developer PAC
Austin  $    2,000.00 (websearch: Developer) Trust "Tynberg LLC currently is involved in an urban development project in Leander, TX, which is located just minutes north of Austin, TX along the 183A Toll Road."
Dallas  $        100.00 Engineer (Civil) Schnabel Engineers "We provide specialized expertise and design for geotechnical, dam, and tunnel engineering projects across the United States and worldwide. "
Dallas  $        100.00 Engineer (Civil) Schnabel Engineers "We provide specialized expertise and design for geotechnical, dam, and tunnel engineering projects across the United States and worldwide. "
Cedar Park  $        200.00 Business Consultant - public sector projects  J. L. Powers "Mitch works as a Senior Consultant for J.L. Powers and Associates, advising clients on gaining access to public sector projects, strategic planning, public-private partnerships,"
Liberty Hill  $        100.00 Consultant Self Retired Leander ISD Superintendent
Austin  $        250.00 Business Owner - Civil Engineering K. Friese and Associates "civil engineering consulting services to our public sector clients"
Leander  $        100.00 Business executive unknown
Buda  $        100.00 Manager - Civil Engineering CobbFendley Civil Engineering 
Austin  $        100.00 Admin unknown
Pflugerville  $        200.00 Teacher Pflugerville ISD
Ft. Worth  $        300.00 Developers PAC
Wimberly  $        100.00 Planning Consultant  XBlink
Pagosa Springs, CO  $        500.00 Retired Engineer

McGregor  $        250.00 Engineers (Civil) Walker Partners Civil Engineering 
Austin  $    1,000.00 Developer Self
Austin  $        250.00 Construction American Constructors
Driftwood  $        250.00 COO (Civil Engineering) Walker Partners Civil Engineering 
Austin  $        100.00 Attorney (Developers) GDHM "practice includes representing developers, investors, and companies in the acquisition, disposition, leasing, development and entitlement of improved and raw land."
Round Rock  $        350.00 unknown unknown
Austin  $        100.00 Architect Page
Austin  $        250.00 Attorney  Armbrust & Brown "represents clients before city and county governmental entities in land-use and business matters"
Austin  $        100.00 Real estate Cresent Communities
Austin  $        100.00 Real estate self
Austin  $        100.00 Business owner self (web search:  Founder, Smart City Policy Group) "He currently serves as Founder of Smart City Policy Group, a government and public solutions firm working to help cities and states create effective regulations for the Sharing Economy, the Gig Economy - known as the New Economy."
Austin  $        250.00 Attorney (web search:  real estate attorney) Metcalfe, Wolff, Stewart,Williams
Austin  $        250.00 Attorney Metcalfe, Wolff, Stewart,Williams
Austin  $        250.00 Attorney Metcalfe, Wolff, Stewart,Williams
Austin  $        250.00 Attorney Metcalfe, Wolff, Stewart,Williams
Austin  $        250.00 unknown unknown "The Novy Company is a full service medical/professional commercial real estate firm established in Austin Texas by founder Brian Novy."
Austin  $        300.00 Developers PAC
Dallas  $    1,500.00 Principal Stantec Real estate development
Dallas  $    1,500.00 Principal Catlyn Capital "Catlyn Capital Corp. operates as a real estate investment company."
Dallas  $    1,500.00 Real estate Catlyn Capital "Catlyn Capital Corp. operates as a real estate investment company."
Dallas  $    1,500.00 Real estate Catlyn Capital "Catlyn Capital Corp. operates as a real estate investment company."
Austin  $        200.00 Commercial Real estate ARA Newmark
Leander  $    3,000.00 Developer MPE Realty
Cedar Park  $        100.00 business owner Mary Henderson associates
Leander  $        200.00 unknown unknown
Austin  $        250.00 Commercial Real estate unknown
Leander  $        250.00 Builder Giddens Homes
Austin  $        250.00 Home builders PAC


















































HILL CAMPAIGN FINANCE REPORT - CONTRIBUTORS


City  Amount  Occupation Employer Notes
Leander  $   2,000.00 CIO HP
Leander  $       300.00 Realtor

Georgetown  $       500.00 Realtor

Austin  $       500.00 Realtor

Cedar Park  $       100.00 Realtor

Leander  $       500.00 Realtor

Georgetown  $       401.00
PAC IN KIND
Georgetown  $   5,000.00
PAC support pro-business minded candidates in Leander
Leander  $       150.00

Planning/Dev
Leander  $       250.00


Leander  $       100.00 Handy man self
Austin  $   1,000.00

Land Developer
Leander  $       100.00 contractor self
Leander  $       150.00


Lakeway  $       100.00 attorney
real estate
Leander  $       100.00


Leander  $       100.00